Momma In The Mitten

When you’re pregnant, building your baby registry feels like a mix of excitement and overwhelm. There are endless lists, must-have guides, and baby store checklists that tell you what to buy. But here’s the truth most new moms will only admit after the baby arrives: some of the most important items you’ll need are for you — not the baby.

Sure, the cute onesies, bottles, and swaddles have their place, but if you skip over the less glamorous items, you may find yourself sending your partner on a last-minute store run at midnight. That’s why I pulled together this list of unpopular baby registry must-haves — the postpartum items no one tells you about, but every new mom will be glad to have.

👉 To make it easier, I’ve gathered all of these products in my Amazon Storefront. You can check them out here and add them straight to your registry or postpartum kit.

1. Adult Diapers (Yes, Really!)

Let’s get this one out of the way — adult diapers are a postpartum game changer. Forget the thin hospital pads or the mesh underwear that never seems to stay in place. With adult diapers, you get:

–Full coverage protection for heavy postpartum bleeding.

–Comfort and security when you’re moving around in those first few days.

–No leaks at night, which means one less thing to stress about while you’re sleep-deprived.

Many moms swear by brands like Always Discreet or Depends Silhouette. They look and feel less bulky than you’d think, and the convenience alone makes them worth adding to your registry.

2. Sitz Bath (With Epsom Salt Blends)

If you’ve never heard of a sitz bath, it’s a small plastic tub that fits over your toilet. You fill it with warm water, sit down, and let your lower body soak. It sounds simple, but it’s incredibly soothing for postpartum recovery.

I recommend adding sitz bath blends with Epsom salts to the water for extra relief. These blends often include ingredients like lavender, chamomile, or witch hazel, which can:

–Relieve soreness and swelling after delivery.

–Promote healing for stitches, tearing, or hemorrhoids.

–Give you a few quiet minutes of self-care in the middle of a hectic recovery.

⚠️ Note: If you’ve had a C-section, you may not need a sitz bath for healing. However, the salts can still be used later for a regular relaxing soak (once cleared by your doctor) or even just to ease sore muscles.

This is one of those simple, inexpensive tools that makes a huge difference when you’re recovering and adjusting to life with a newborn.

3. Perineal Ice Packs

Those perineal ice packs you’ll get from the hospital? You’ll want more. Trust me. Cooling relief is one of the quickest ways to soothe the swelling and discomfort that comes with postpartum recovery.

Here’s why to add them to your registry:

–Immediate relief from perineal pain and stitches.

–Reusable options are available (gel packs you freeze and slip into a soft sleeve).

–Disposable instant packs are great for those first few days when convenience is everything.

⚠️ Note: If you’ve had a C-section, you may not need these for perineal healing — but they’re still useful. Ice packs can be used on sore muscles, bumps, or even for headaches. They’re one of those items that never go to waste.

Some moms even rotate between warm sitz baths and ice packs to balance comfort and healing.

4. High-Waisted Underwear

Forget your cute low-rise panties — after birth, you’ll want high-waisted underwear that’s soft, stretchy, and supportive.

Why high-waisted?

-They won’t dig into your incision if you’ve had a C-section.

-They fit comfortably over adult diapers or pads.

-They give you that gentle “held in” feeling when everything feels a little out of place.

Opt for dark colors, breathable cotton, and multipacks that you won’t mind tossing later if needed.

5. Nursing Pajamas

Last but definitely not least — nursing pajamas. Yes, technically you can sleep in oversized T-shirts, but nursing pajamas make those middle-of-the-night feedings so much easier.

Here’s why they’re a must-have:

–Easy access for breastfeeding or pumping.

–Soft fabrics that feel good on sensitive skin.

–Stylish enough that you can wear them when guests drop by (bonus: no one will know they’re technically pajamas).

Many sets even include matching robes, which can be a confidence boost when you’re adjusting to your new body and routine.

Why These “Unpopular” Items Belong on Your Registry

Baby registries are often full of baby gear, but the truth is, babies don’t need much beyond food, diapers, and love. Moms, however, need support and comfort — and that starts with recovery items that help you heal, rest, and feel human again.

Adding these “unpopular” items to your registry might raise an eyebrow or two, but you’ll be so glad you did when you don’t have to scramble for them later. In fact, many experienced moms say these were the most valuable items they received.

🎁 Bonus Gift Ideas for Moms-to-Be

If you’re reading this list not for yourself but to shop for a friend, sister, or daughter who’s expecting, here are a few thoughtful extras you can add alongside the postpartum must-haves:

Candles → something calming and cozy for those late nights.

Favorite snacks → easy grab-and-go fuel for tired moms.

Slippers → comfy and practical for shuffling around the house.

Soft blanket → perfect for nursing, napping, or just cozying up.

Large water bottle → hydration is everything for new moms, especially if they’re breastfeeding.

Bottle of wine or sparkling juice → a celebratory treat for when she’s ready.

These small but thoughtful gifts go a long way in helping a new mom feel cared for.

Once you’ve stocked up on these postpartum must-haves, the next step is making sure your diaper bag is ready to go. Check out my full list of Diaper Bag Must-Haves for practical items you’ll actually use every time you leave the house with baby.

Final Thoughts

Whether you’re a first-time mom or preparing for baby number two, don’t overlook your own recovery in the baby registry process. Stocking up on essentials like adult diapers, sitz bath blends, ice packs, high-waisted underwear, and nursing pajamas may not feel glamorous, but they’ll make your postpartum experience smoother, more comfortable, and far less stressful.

And when you’re up at 2 a.m. with your newborn, you’ll be grateful for every single one.

✨ Want to skip the guesswork? I’ve already rounded up these must-have postpartum items in my Amazon Storefront. It’s an easy one-stop spot to grab everything you’ll need for recovery.

⚠️ Disclaimer

I’m not a medical professional. This post is based on personal experience and shared advice from other moms. Always consult with your healthcare provider about your postpartum recovery and before trying new products.